Best 5 Cup Coffee Makers In 2021 – Which One To Choose?

A cup of coffee in the morning isn’t just a wake-up call; it is the best way to start your day and ensure that the rest of your day goes smoothly. It awakens all your senses and instantly enhances your mood. That first sip of freshly brewed and deliciously rich coffee running down our throats is a heavenly experience. And since coffee machines come in varying shapes and sizes, it wouldn’t be very practical to choose an incredibly small coffee machine that can only make 1 or 2 cups of coffee.

best 5 cup coffee maker

These days, there are great modern and stylish coffee machines that will suffice not just your coffee needs, but also your family’s. So, in order to ensure that this start to your day is perfect, we have listed the best 5 cup coffee makers that are not only budget friendly, but also produce high quality, flavorful coffee within a minutes.

The Best 5 cup Coffee Makers In 2021 Review

Below is a list of top rated 5 cup coffee makers. Check each and everyone and select the one which suits your need.

1. Mr. Coffee Advanced Brew 5 Cup Coffee Maker

You may be very well aware of this brand because Mr. Coffee is a well-established and recognized brand in the coffee machines industry. Apart from being inexpensive and affordable, their coffee machines produce top-notch quality coffee that you will love and adore. Its unique characteristic is that it is programmable and has very user-friendly controls. The glass carafe has a huge capacity and is see-through, permitting you to check on the water levels easily.

The Mr. Coffee 5 cup coffee maker has another unique feature which is the delay brew timer. The delay brew timer permits you to set a timer to brew ahead of time so on lazy mornings, you can wake up to freshly brewed, steaming hot cups of coffee. It also offers a Grab A Cup, Auto Pause that enables you to pause the brewing cycle and pour yourself a cup of coffee before the brewing process is even completed. Furthermore, it also includes a removable filter basket that can be cleaned and reused. The auto shut off functionality is a major advantage for those who may forget to turn off the coffee machine in a hurry.

Pros
  • Refillable water reservoir
  • Delay brew timer
  • Easy to use controls
  • Options are programmable
  • Variety of colors
  • Compact
Cons
  • 1 hour shut off not very accurate
  • Not durable

2. Bonavita 5 Cup Stainless Steel Carafe Coffee Brewer

The Bonavita BV1500TS is one of the finest 5 cup coffee machines out there. Apart from its compact and sleek design, it is also a very unique appliance that offers a huge array of features at a very affordable price. It has a pre-infusion mode that soaks the freshly roasted ground coffee that allows it to extract every last bit of flavor from your coffee beans. This means the coffee is more saturated and degassed before the brewing takes places. Hence you are provided with an authentic and deeply rich and flavorsome cup of coffee every single time.

The most unique feature of the Bonavita BV1500TS is that it has a thermal stainless-steel carafe. Most coffee machines come with a glass carafe as it is a cheaper and more accessible option. However, the thermal stainless-steel carafe is more durable and less prone to damage. It also seals the heat inside and keeps your coffee hot and fresh for longer. Furthermore, it utilizes a powerful 1100-watt heater to ensure your coffee is being brewed at the optimal temperature.

Although it has been constructed from plastic which is not as durable as stainless steel, all the plastic parts are BPA-free, easily removable and dishwasher safe. In case you forget to switch off your coffee machine, it also has an auto shut off option which will automatically turn off your coffee machine and prevent wastage of energy.

Pros
  • Pre-infusion mode
  • Powerful 1100-watt heater
  • Includes a thermal carafe
  • Automatic shut off 
  • Dishwasher safe parts
  • Detachable parts
Cons
  • Few drops left in carafe always
  • No heating plate included

3.  BLACK + DECKER 5-Cup CM0700BZ

BLACK+DECKER has made its name not just in the coffee machine industry but in the entirety of the kitchen appliances industry. They are very well known to create supreme quality appliances that are very affordable. The BLACK+DECKER CM0700BZ is one such masterpiece produced by this amazing brand. It has a very artistic and aesthetic look to it and is very sleek and compact in size.

It comes with an ergonomically designed glass carafe that offers drip free pouring and has a detachable lid which makes the cleaning process easier for you. It also includes a hot plate that keeps your coffee warm and fresh for very long. Apart from the very simple and user-friendly operation, it also offers an easy view water window.

The best aspect of this, however, is the sneak-a-cup feature. This feature pauses the brewing process and stops the flow of the coffee and permits you to pour a cup for yourself without causing any mess on the surface. It includes a permanent grounds filter that is very easy to clean and reuse.

Pros
  • Sneak a cup feature
  • Easy view water window
  • Comes with a reusable filter
  • Easy to use
  • Affordable
  • 2-year warranty
Cons
  • Doesn’t have variety in coffee options
  • Not durable

4. Zojirushi EC-DAC50 Zutto 5-cup Drip Coffee Maker

The Zojirushi EC-DAC50 Zutto is one of the finest 5-cup drip coffee makers out there. Although a little on the pricier side, it produces very rich and delicious coffee within a few minutes. It has a very space-saving and practical design. It comes with a glass carafe and a transparent water window, that allows you to check on the coffee and water levels and refill accordingly without any hassle.

It has a very unique charcoal filter inside its glass carafe that is not only long lasting but will also purify your water as you use it. The best part, however, is that it has a very special keep warm option which prevents your coffee from becoming stale.

Once you turn it on, it will stay on the entire day until and unless you turn it off. So, your coffee remains fresh and hot for as long as you’d like.

Pros
  • Includes charcoal filter
  • Easy to use
  • Keep hot functionality
  • Removable water tank
  • Transparent water window
  • Includes measuring spoon
Cons
  • Expensive
  • No automatic shut off

5. Capresso 5-Cup Mini Drip Coffee Maker

As you all are aware, Capresso is a very well established and well-known brand in the coffee maker industry. They are known for their great quality and affordable coffee makers. The Capresso 5 cup mini drip coffee maker has a very trendy and attractive look with a black and stainless-steel design.

It has the perfect sized carafe which has a 5-cup capacity and the fact that it is so compact makes it easy to store in your cabinets. It also has a very user-friendly operation and has programmable options which save you lot of hassle and effort. The best part, however, is that it comes with a hot plate that keeps your coffee piping hot and fresh for two whole hours. And if you’re in a rush and can’t wait for the entire brewing process to complete, it has a drip stop functionality which allows you to pour a cup while the brewing process is going on.

Gone are the days wherein you would need to use messy paper filters and throw them out after one use. The Capresso 5 cup mini drip includes a GoldTone Filter, which is reusable, and it is much easier to clean.

Pros
  • Compact
  • The brewing temperature is very hot
  • User friendly
  • Programmable
  • Able to stop mid-pour
  • Auto shut off
Cons
  • The carafe is prone to breaking

6. Amazon Basics 5-Cup Coffee maker

Amazon Basics is well known for maintain a great balance between price and quality for all its products. The Amazon Basics 5 cup coffee maker is an extremely affordable option for all those who are on a budget.

It has a sleek and stylish design with its matte black exterior and glass carafe and has a very user friendly operation with just one on/off switch. It is compact and capable of brewing 5 cups of coffee in one go which is nearly 25 ounces of coffee. It also provides a reusable basket-shaped filter that needs to be cleaned with hand.

The glass carafe also, can only be washed by hand and the parts are not dishwasher safe. Although the glass carafe may not be the most ideal option for sealing in the heat, the Amazon Basics 5 cup coffee maker comes with a hot plate that will ensure that your coffee stays warm for really long.

Thanks to the Anti-drip function, you can pause the brewing process and pour yourself a cup without causing any mess. And it also has a one-year warranty.

Pros
  • Affordable
  • Includes reusable filter
  • Able to stop mid-pour
  • Auto shut off
  • Compact
Cons
  • Carafe can only be washed by hand
  • Slow brewing
  • Filter not dishwasher safe

7. Holstein Housewares HH-0914701E 5-Cup Coffee Maker

For all those who enjoy decorating their homes with quaint and quirky appliances, this is the perfect coffee machine for you. The Holstein Housewares is a one of a kind, 5 cup coffee maker. This stunning contraption comes in a variety of very stunning and unique colors that will add the necessary pop of color to your kitchen: mint, teal and red.

It comes with a glass carafe, which alongside the level markings, allows you to keep an eye on the level of your coffee. But the Holstein Housewares HH-0914701E isn’t just premium quality in its looks but its performance as well. It produces richly flavored and strong coffee within just a few minutes. It also has a very easy-to-use operation with just one ON/OFF switch.

If you’re in a hurry and cannot wait for the brewing process to complete, then no need to fret because this amazing contraption also provides a brew pause feature that allows you to stop the brewing cycle and pour yourself a cup of coffee without causing any drippage.

The most pleasantly surprising part is that it includes a measuring spoon and a removable cone filter. This makes your coffee brewing process more precise and the cleaning process easier and simpler.

Pros
  • Variety of unique colors
  • Brew pause options
  • Compact
  • Includes measuring spoon
  • Includes reusable filter
  • 1 year warranty
Cons
  • Difficulty in removing filter

8. BLACK+DECKER 5-Cup DCM600B

The BLACK+DECKER DCM600B is a stunning contraption. The all-black design gives this coffee machine a very stylish and professional look. If a plethora of buttons are confusing for you, then you’re in luck because this 5-cup coffee maker has only one lighted on/off switch. Furthermore, it has level markings on the carafe for the coffee as well and a see-through water window.

It comes with a DuraLife glass carafe which is much more durable and sturdier than other glass carafes. The non-stick hot plate ensures that your coffee stays hot and fresh for a long time. It also comes with an easily removable filter which is dishwash safe and can be reused.

Although there are some serious design flaws in this coffee machine. There have been complaints of the brewing process being incredibly slow and that it does not produce strong and rich coffee.

Pros
  • One-touch start operation
  • Easy to clean warming plate
  • User friendly
  • Durable
  • Compact 
  • Dishwasher safe
Cons
  • Very slow
  • The flavor of the coffee is not strong

9. Yama Glass Siphon Vacuum.

You will be pleasantly surprised when you come across this contraption. The Yama Glass Siphon Vacuum has the most unusual and unique design and structure. It looks like an hourglass and something right out of a chemistry lab, with its inverted glass water basin atop its glass carafe. Even its handle is very ornate and finely crafted.

Although it is a bit complicated, this would be the center of attraction in your kitchen with its beautiful finish and stunning design. It doesn’t have an electric source but rather utilizes an open flame and you would need to light the burner which is placed below the glass carafe in order to star the brewing process.

But there is no need to worry as you can find plenty of video tutorials and make use of the included instructions.

The specialty of the Yama Siphon Gravity Coffee Maker is that it uses a vacuum technology that ensures that all the aromas and essential oils of your coffee are locked and sealed in, hence maximizing the flavor of your coffee. It also includes reusable cloth filters that can easily be washed.

Furthermore, this beautifully hand-crafted equipment is made of non-porous, hand-blown borosilicate glass that does not absorb any chemicals or odors. The best part, however, is that you are given full control to manage the temperature, brew consistency and water ratios which allows you to get a personalized cup of coffee that is perfect for you and accurate to your preferences.

Pros
  • Durable
  • Very well crafted
  • Comes with a reusable cloth filter
  • Grants you full control
  • 2-year warranty 
  • Non-porous glass
Cons
  • Very expensive
  • Difficult and confusing to use

Buying Guide

Factors to consider before buying best 5 cup coffee maker. Check out each and every point and take into consideration while planning to get your favorite coffee maker.

Filters:

There is a lot of variety in filters. Mainly, there are permanent filters and temporary filters. Temporary filters can be used one time only and will need to be thrown out after use. Permanent filters can be washed and reused and are a much better option with regards to reducing waste and saving the planet. And it would also save you the money required to purchase temporary filters. Filters also come in various shapes. Some are comical while others are flat shaped. The conical ones are known to be better at extracting maximum flavor whereas the flat ones are more accessible and easier to use.

Carafe:

Carafes come in two types. They are either constructed from glass or have a thermal stainless-steel construction. Most coffee makers have glass carafes which make it easier to see through the carafe. But thermal carafes are more durable. Also make sure to check the size of the carafe depending on your needs. A larger carafe would be the perfect choice for you if you need to produce large amounts of coffee in one go. However, a smaller sized carafe will be most suitable if you do not require to make too many cups at the same time.

Budget:

Most of the 5-cup coffee makers that we have listed above are quite affordable and budget friendly. Although they produce great quality coffee, they may not provide you with a lot of features. Some of the coffee makers that are on the pricier side, however, give you a wide array of features that enhance the quality and taste of your coffee.

Design:

Depending on your needs and preferences, you can easily find a grand variety in the designs of the coffee machines. Apart from very trendy and innovative looking designs, it is important to focus on the build and size of the coffee machine. Ensure that the size of the machine is according to your needs and space available in your kitchen. And also make sure that it has been made out of strong and durable materials.

Glass:

Most coffee machines have a glass carafe. The benefit of the carafe being made from glass is that it is see-through, and you can easily see the number of coffee grounds that need to be poured in and when the carafe needs to be refilled. It is also a cheaper option in comparison to the stainless-steel carafe. However, the glass carafe is more prone to breaking and is not very durable. Although it gives a great aesthetic to the coffee maker, it does not keep the heat in for very long and this causes the coffee to become stale quite fast.

Stainless Steel:

Some coffee machines also have a thermal stainless-steel carafe. This is a much better option in comparison to the glass carafe because it is more durable and long lasting. It also keeps your coffee hot for a really long time and thus your coffee stays fresher for longer. However, it is not see-through, so you will need to detach it from the machine to check if it needs refilling. And it is a tad more expensive than the glass carafe

Features:

A lot of coffee makers despite being incredibly affordable, provide a lot of features. Depending on your needs you can select which features are a must in your coffee maker. Some coffee machines are programmable and have a very easy-to-use operation and others provide an auto shut-off timer that will switch off the machine after a certain amount of time in order to save energy. Some other features are the included reusable filters and also brew pause functionality.

Durability:

The main exterior of the coffee machines is either made of hard plastic or stainless steel. While the hard plastic is quite strong, it is not very long-lasting or durable and has the risk of breaking quite early on. However, the coffee machines constructed from stainless steel are far sturdier and more durable and not prone to damage.

Warranty:

Checking the warranty is the most important thing when purchasing a coffee maker. Ensure that the warranty of the coffee maker you would like to buy is for a longer time period so that your coffee maker lasts longer.

Ease of cleaning:

Another incredibly important aspect to check is how easy it is to clean the coffee maker. Ensure that the parts are detachable and also dishwasher safe. That makes the cleaning process easy and hassle free and will save you lots of time and effort.

FAQ

1. How do I make the most of the 5-cup coffee maker?

In order to make the best use of your 5-cup coffee maker, you need to follow a few, very simple steps. Firstly, you would need a grinder to grind your coffee beans. Freshly ground coffee tastes much more delicious and authentic.

Then after your coffee has been grinded, you can add then to the filter in your coffee maker and add the desired amount of water in your carafe. Then you just have to start the brewing process and wait for a couple minutes and voila! Your steamy and fresh cup of coffee is ready for you to relish. Also make sure to clean your carafe and your coffee filter regularly.

2. What features an ideal machine should have?

The main goal for a coffee machine should be to make a piping hot, top-notch quality cup of coffee and to make it quickly. Furthermore, it should have a reasonably sized carafe that has the capacity of at least 5 to 8 cups of coffee. The inclusion of a hot plate is incredibly important so that your coffee doesn’t go stale and remains hot for a very long time.

Coffee machines also offer features like an automatic shut-off function that helps you save energy and reduce heat emission. It is also better to purchase coffee machines that come with a permanent filter that can be cleaned and reused. Another amazing feature that an ideal machine should have is the brew-pause options.

The Final Verdict

All the coffee machines that we have listed above are the best 5 cup coffee makers that offer you premium quality and delicious coffee within the span of just a few minutes. However, the absolute best one out of all these is the Bonavita 5 Cup Stainless Steel Carafe, Coffee Maker.

It is not only affordable and produces high-quality coffee, but it also has the most unique features and goes above and beyond to ensure that your coffee retains all its essential flavors. The thermal stainless-steel carafe insulates the heat and keeps your coffee fresh for a long period of time. Apart from that, the powerful heater ensures that your coffee is being brewed at the optimal temperature. And to top it all off, it has a pre-infusion mode that allows degassing and saturation of your coffee grounds before the brewing process starts, in order to ensure that every last drop of flavor is extracted from the ground coffee.

The second-best option on our list is Mr. Coffee Advanced Brew 5 Cup Coffee Maker because of its unique features and its commitment to warrant that your coffee absorbs and preserves all its authentic flavors. It is programmable, unlike the other options on our list, and has a very simple and uncomplicated operation.

It has a delay brew timer that allows you to set a timer to make your cup of the coffee way ahead of time. This way you can sleep in and not have to put in any effort, and you will be greeted by a fresh cup of coffee every morning. It also offers a grab a cup feature that allows you to stop the brewing process and pour yourself a cup before the brewing process is finished. The auto shut-off timer ensures that energy is not wasted, and heat emission is reduced. After an hour of inactivity, it automatically turns off the coffee machine.